Net exposure of hundreds of doctors in Wenzhou eats a rebate from the hospital

On the early morning of the 8th, there was a special black shark on the Internet called "Wenzhou Fuyi and Fuzhou Doctor's Rebate Rebate: Detailed List of Rebate for Jiangxi Jimin Cinnamate Pharmaceutical Xingnaojing Injection in March! Posts have caused concern among netizens. A salesman who claims to have left the company from a pharmaceutical company in Jiangxi broke the news that more than 110 doctors from the First Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical College and the Second Affiliated Hospital of Yuwen (Yuying Children's Hospital) had eaten the "rebate" of the drug "Xingjingjingjing". Aroused a lot of netizens' arguments that the two state-owned top-three hospitals in Wenzhou have become the target of public criticism. Xinhua News Agency’s “China Network Affairs” reporter conducted an investigation and verification on this matter.

[Core network affairs] 100 doctors "rebate" rebate up to 20%

At 2:22 a.m. on June 8th, a well-known forum in Wenzhou “703804” appeared with a special shady “Wenzhou Fuyi and Fushun II Doctors Rebate: Jiangxi Jimin Credible Pharmaceutical Industry Xingnaojing Infusion Rebate March detailed list! ” Posts, posting netizens “wzkldd” broke the news that: he is a salesman from the Jiangxi Jimin Citi Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., and he feels guilty that he has earned a lot of “bad money” from the patients. The mode of operation of this company is to provide doctors with rebates for the purpose of pharmaceutical sales. It involves more than 110 doctors from the First Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical College and the Second Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical College. The rebate rate for doctors is as high as 20%.

In the form of a list, the net posts listed in detail the names of the more than 110 "rebate-taking" doctors of the two hospitals in this year's March of this year, their job numbers, their department wards, drug names, drug prescriptions, sales, rebates, and the amount of deductions. The total amount of rebates in the hospital and other information. Such as attached to a doctor Chen Moumou, job number 53**, neurology clinic, in March with "sweeping brain static needle" 123, sales amount of 9348 yuan, rebate 1968 yuan, attached to a hospital full month commission of a total of 116,224 yuan.

This rebate list shows that in March the doctors in the two major hospitals had commissions of as little as tens of dollars, and as many as 1,000 yuan. The high amount of Yin's rebate was as high as 25,744 yuan. The two major hospitals totaled more than 270,000 yuan in March. The list also shows that the specifications for "sweeping brains and needles" are 10 ml, and the retail price of each hospital is 76 yuan, of which the rebate is 16 yuan, and the calculated rebate ratio is 21%.

[Reporter's investigation] The basic contents are true but the hospital actually claimed to be "hacking" There are two major doubts in the two hospitals.

The "China Network Affairs" reporter contacted Wenyi You Yiyi and Fu Youyi. The hospital all said that the net name, job number (actually serial number), department, drug name, number of drugs used, amount of drug used, etc. were disclosed on the net post. The contents displayed on the computer basically match.

However, the two hospitals have denied that doctors have "rebate" behavior, but also that the leakage of information on the use of drugs may be "hacking."

Even more puzzling is the fact that the two hospitals denied that the doctors had eaten the “rebate” because they did not find any problems after self-examination. Chen Chengshui, deputy secretary of the party committee and secretary of the Disciplinary Committee of the First Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical College, told the “China Network” reporter that the network post involved 21 doctors and 15 wards in the hospital and that an investigation has been conducted. Chen Chengshui said: "So far, all clinicians have denied accepting kickbacks." Xu Hui, director of the administrative office of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University, also said: "After interviews with each doctor, the issue of rebates does not exist."

However, even though the two major hospitals have denied doctors "rebates," the reporter found several anomalies in the investigation:

First, the list of net posts provided detailed and detailed descriptions of doctors' individual and medication information. The list clearly showed that the records of the "brained and static needles" were written in more than 10 departments of the two major hospitals. Is "sweeping the brain and static needle" to cure all diseases?

Chen Chengshui said that the main function of Xingnaojing injection is to promote brain resuscitation, and it is used for acute cerebral hemorrhage, brain tissue lesions, and vascular accidents.

However, the list shows that the departments that use the “Sticking Cerebral Needle” include not only neurology, cerebrovascular, neurology, neurosurgery, emergency department, traumatology, even gynecology, stomatology, ophthalmology, gastroenterology, and respiratory medicine. Laparoscopic surgery, endocrinology, nephrology, and children's infectious diseases are among them.

Second, the drug prices of the two hospitals suspected of eating “rebate” were significantly higher.

The reporter learned from some other hospitals that the purchase price of each “suddenly minded” injection is around 35 yuan, and the sales price is generally around 43 yuan, while the sales prices of the two hospitals exposed are as high as 76 yuan.

The two hospitals did not respond positively to the high selling price. Chen Chengshui said: “In view of the current situation, we have decided that the whole hospital will suspend the use of 'suddenly energized static needles' and will treat them according to future investigations.”

[Feedback] Internet users strongly demand that third parties be involved in the investigation

At present, Wenzhou's “hundred doctors take pharmaceutical kickbacks” continues to ferment on the Internet. Internet users strongly demand that third parties be involved in the investigation. They should also truthfully deal with the relevant hospitals and doctors.

The reporter initially briefed the Forum on thousands of Internet commentators and found that more than 95% of Internet users believe that "medical rebates existed" and questioned the hospital's self-examination form; only 4% believed that the hospital's attitude towards the matter is worthy of recognition. Another 1% of Internet users think this is a fraud.

Internet users and others have questioned the effectiveness of hospital surveys and believe that relying solely on the investigation of the hospital is not enough and should be investigated by third-party forces such as the Commission for Discipline Inspection.

The netizen said, "One night," "Another metaphor, the son stole something, asked his parents to investigate whether his son had stolen it. The next day, the parents did not steal the investigation."

Netizens "Truth of Justice" appeal: must the Commission for Discipline Inspection intervene! One hundred percent rebate is found! (Two hospitals) This investigation is to deceive the masses of the people. It is a corrupt vested interest who ignores the law!

The netizen "size Q" thinks: The hospital's self-examination will always be no problem, and the parties will always deny it. Acknowledged that the rice bowl was no guarantee.

The netizen “Eastern Bad Boy” pointed out from a professional point of view that the effect of Xingnaojing Injection is similar to that of Angong Niuhuang Wan. As a proprietary Chinese medicine, it has no significant effect on the condition itself, but it is not easy to cause serious consequences even if it is abused. In fact, it can be said that in most cases it is available and unavailable. There are two kinds of doctors when the availability is not available: One is to hold a dead horse as a living horse doctor when the condition is so serious that the doctor can't do anything, but also because of psychological comfort to the patient and his family. The other is to use a doctor who “takes care of this kind of medicine without causing death”, whether or not he has to use this medicine, “all look at the money”, in order to use the medicine in a random manner.

Some netizens also pointed out that the whistleblower should have more detailed information to confirm whether there is a phenomenon of “rebate rebate”. The netizen "Urban Girl" believes that according to the principle of who advocates proof, the person who broke the news must provide evidence to prove that the list of running water alone is not enough to prove that the doctor has got a kickback.

Next:Installation, use and regulation of marine diesel generator sets
Previous post: Funeral home miscarriage to the relatives crying wrong person official emergency mediation